U.S. District Court Northern District of West Virginia Public Opinions
-- Opinions are provided here for informational purposes only. Log into PACER for the official record.
-- Use options at the right to search results.
-- Search date range using 01/01/2008 or 1/1/08.
-- Date defaults to current year.
-- Opinions of Recent Years:          
SEARCH
Case Number:    
Date Range: to 
Party:
    

Date Filed Case Opinion Judge
02/26/2015Civil Action No. 14-0042
King v. Rubenstein et al
Doc No. 27 (memorandum opinion and order rejecting in part)
Doc No. 27-1 (memorandum opinion and order rejecting in part)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/26/2015Criminal No. 12-0032
USA v. Crow
Doc No. 197 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
02/25/2015Criminal No. 15-0016
USA v. Franklin
Doc No. 13 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/25/2015Criminal No. 15-0008
USA v. Honuker
Doc No. 16 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/25/2015Civil Action No. 14-0134
Rahmi v. Sheehan
Doc No. 10 (memorandum opinion and order)
Doc No. 10-1 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/24/2015Criminal No. 04-0042
USA v. Chase
Doc No. 80 (order)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/24/2015Civil Action No. 14-0001
Moorning v. Warden Purdue
Doc No. 36 (order adopting)
Doc No. 36-1 (order adopting)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/20/2015Criminal No. 15-0008
USA v. Schrader
Doc No. 19 (order)
Doc No. 20 (order)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/20/2015Civil Action No. 15-0005
Ruff v. Odom
Doc No. 12 (order adopting report and recommendation)
Doc No. 12-1 (order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
02/20/2015Civil Action No. 14-0215
Bank v. Alliance Security Inc. et al
Doc No. 51 (order)
Doc No. 51-1 (order)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/20/2015Civil Action No. 14-0132
Godlove v. Martinsburg Senior Towers, LP et al
Doc No. 34 (order)
Doc No. 34-1 (order)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/19/2015Civil Action No. 14-0067
Camastro et al v. West Virginia Alcohol Beverage Control Commission et al
Doc No. 102 (memorandum opinion and order confirming pronouncement of the court issuing a pre)
Doc No. 102-1 (memorandum opinion and order confirming pronouncement of the court issuing a pre)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
02/19/2015Criminal No. 11-0065
USA v. Condrey
Doc No. 189 (order)
Doc No. 189-1 (order)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
02/18/2015Civil Action No. 14-0032
Lamarr v. Jackson et al
Doc No. 50 (order)
Doc No. 50-1 (order)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/18/2015Civil Action No. 11-0163
Sheehan v. Saoud et al
Doc No. 136 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/18/2015Criminal No. 04-0009
USA v. Yule
Doc No. 714 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
02/18/2015Criminal No. 01-0010
USA v. Farmer
Doc No. 605 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
02/17/2015Civil Action No. 14-0037
Williams v. USA
Doc No. 14 (order)
Doc No. 14-1 (order)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
02/17/2015Criminal No. 13-0010
USA v. Williams
Doc No. 72 (order)
Doc No. 72-1 (order)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
02/13/2015Criminal No. 15-0013
USA v. Harris
Doc No. 11 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/13/2015Criminal No. 14-0100
USA v. Vecchio
Doc No. 14 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/13/2015Criminal No. 14-0057
USA v. Redman
Doc No. 46 (order of pretrial conference)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/13/2015Criminal No. 14-0092
USA v. Cole
Doc No. 13 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/13/2015Criminal No. 14-0086
USA v. Miller
Doc No. 99 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/13/2015Criminal No. 14-0078
USA v. Dailey
Doc No. 112 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/13/2015Criminal No. 09-0028
USA v. Gardner
Doc No. 62 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/12/2015Criminal No. 14-0045
USA v. Pritt
Doc No. 29 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/12/2015Criminal No. 14-0042
USA v. Sharp
Doc No. 84 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/12/2015Criminal No. 14-0042
USA v. Scott
Doc No. 83 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/12/2015Criminal No. 14-0042
USA v. Cordero
Doc No. 82 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/12/2015Criminal No. 14-0042
USA v. Calain
Doc No. 81 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/12/2015Criminal No. 14-0041
USA v. Mathes
Doc No. 22 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/11/2015Criminal No. 14-0037
USA v. Justice
Doc No. 45 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/11/2015Criminal No. 14-0036
USA v. Dean
Doc No. 28 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/11/2015Civil Action No. 14-0080
Hamilton v. American Public University System et al
Doc No. 9 (memorandum opinion and order)
Doc No. 9-1 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/11/2015Civil Action No. 14-0023
Salazar v. Holder et al
Doc No. 47 (memorandum opinion and order adopting report and recommendation)
Doc No. 47-1 (memorandum opinion and order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/11/2015Civil Action No. 14-0015
Knisely v. National Better Living Association, Inc et al
Doc No. 149 (order)
Doc No. 150 (order)
 
Magistrate Judge Robert W. Trumble
02/11/2015Civil Action No. 13-0242
Kvech et al v. Alpine Lake Property Owners Association, Inc
Doc No. 90 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/11/2015Criminal No. 06-0046
USA v. Bishop
Doc No. 63 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
02/10/2015Civil Action No. 14-0036
Emigh v. Commissioner of Social Security
Doc No. 32 (order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/10/2015Criminal No. 12-0057
USA v. Carpenter
Doc No. 90 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/10/2015Criminal No. 12-0005
USA v. Bauer
Doc No. 101 (order)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
02/09/2015Criminal No. 14-0091
USA v. Bailes
Doc No. 18 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/09/2015Criminal No. 14-0086
USA v. Wollard
Doc No. 98 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/09/2015Criminal No. 14-0078
USA v. Key
Doc No. 111 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/09/2015Civil Action No. 14-0140
Sayers v. Antero Resources Corporation et al
Doc No. 25 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
02/09/2015Civil Action No. 14-0047
Carter-EL v. Perdue
Doc No. 25 (memorandum opinion and order adopting)
Doc No. 25-1 (memorandum opinion and order adopting)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/06/2015Criminal No. 15-0016
USA v. Franklin
Doc No. 12 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/06/2015Criminal No. 15-0008
USA v. Honuker
Doc No. 13 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
02/06/2015Civil Action No. 14-0126
Hook v. Commissioner of Social Security
Doc No. 14 (order adopting the magistrate judge's report and recommendation and dismissing the case with prejudice from this court's active docket)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/06/2015Civil Action No. 14-0098
Banks v. Commissioner of Social Security
Doc No. 21 (order adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/06/2015Civil Action No. 13-0253
Drake v. USA
Doc No. 16 (order adopting report and recommendation dkt)
Doc No. 16-1 (order adopting report and recommendation dkt)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/06/2015Criminal No. 07-0053
USA v. Drake
Doc No. 357 (order adopting report and recommendation)
Doc No. 357-1 (order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/05/2015Civil Action No. 14-0201
Darby v. Federal Bureau of Investigation
Doc No. 13 (order adopting report and recommendations)
Doc No. 13-1 (order adopting report and recommendations)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/05/2015Civil Action No. 14-0073
O'Dell v. Plumley
Doc No. 22 (order adopting report and recommendation dkt)
Doc No. 22-1 (order adopting report and recommendation dkt)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/05/2015Civil Action No. 14-0023
Knotts v. Commissioner of Social Security
Doc No. 20 (order adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/05/2015Criminal No. 90-0165
USA v. Bowman
Doc No. 170 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
02/03/2015Criminal No. 08-0008
USA v. Powell
Doc No. 87 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
02/03/2015Criminal No. 07-0110
USA v. Lindsay
Doc No. 75 (amended judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
02/03/2015Criminal No. 06-0033
USA v. Pruitt
Doc No. 498 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
02/02/2015Civil Action No. 13-0136
Ellison et al v. The Fund for Theological Education, Inc. et al
Doc No. 65 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/30/2015Civil Action No. 15-0005
Ruff v. Odom
Doc No. 9 (report and recommendation)
Doc No. 9-1 (report and recommendation)
 
Magistrate Judge Robert W. Trumble
01/30/2015Criminal No. 09-0085
USA v. Johnson
Doc No. 118 (order reducing defendant's sentence pursuant to)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
01/29/2015Criminal No. 15-0013
USA v. Harris
Doc No. 10 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/29/2015Criminal No. 14-0100
USA v. Vecchio
Doc No. 13 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/29/2015Civil Action No. 14-0154
GW Rentals, LLC et al v. CLS Group et al
Doc No. 46 (order)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
01/29/2015Criminal No. 14-0092
USA v. Cole
Doc No. 12 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/29/2015Civil Action No. 14-0087
Capelli v. Capelli
Doc No. 7 (memorandum opinion and order affirming decision of the bankruptcy court)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
01/29/2015Criminal No. 14-0086
USA v. Miller
Doc No. 95 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/29/2015Criminal No. 14-0078
USA v. Dailey
Doc No. 110 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/29/2015Civil Action No. 13-0113
Hillberry v. Elder et al
Doc No. 207 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting)
Doc No. 207-1 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/28/2015Civil Action No. 14-0004
Wolfe v. Commissioner of Social Security
Doc No. 19 (memorandum opinion and order adopting)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
01/28/2015Civil Action No. 13-0143
McIntire v. Commissioner of Social Security
Doc No. 21 (order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
01/28/2015Civil Action No. 11-0163
Sheehan v. Saoud et al
Doc No. 103 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/27/2015Civil Action No. 14-0036
Wheeler v. Purdue
Doc No. 23 (order adopting report and recommendation)
Doc No. 23-1 (order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/27/2015Civil Action No. 11-0186
Anderson v. USA
Doc No. 33 (order adopting report and recommendation)
Doc No. 33-1 (order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/27/2015Criminal No. 07-0110
USA v. Lindsay
Doc No. 73 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/27/2015Criminal No. 06-0020
USA v. Anderson
Doc No. 1052 (order adopting report and recommendation)
Doc No. 1052-1 (order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/27/2015Criminal No. 06-0020
USA v. Thompson
Doc No. 1049 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/26/2015Civil Action No. 14-0152
Hooker v. USA
Doc No. 7 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting report and recommendation of magistrate judge)
Doc No. 7-1 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting report and recommendation of magistrate judge)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/26/2015Criminal No. 14-0086
USA v. Ash
Doc No. 94 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/26/2015Criminal No. 14-0086
USA v. Eiseman
Doc No. 93 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/26/2015Criminal No. 14-0046
USA v. Shepard
Doc No. 57 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/26/2015Civil Action No. 14-0021
Dwyer et al v. Range Resources-Appalachia, L.C.C. et al
Doc No. 42 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/26/2015Civil Action No. 14-0019
Daly v. Federal Bureau of Prisons et al
Doc No. 32 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting in part and declining to affirm and adopt in part report and recommendation of magistrate judge)
Doc No. 32-1 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting in part and declining to affirm and adopt in part report and recommendation of magistrate judge)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/26/2015Criminal No. 05-0107
USA v. Jones
Doc No. 235 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/26/2015Criminal No. 02-0028
USA v. Hooker
Doc No. 31 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting report andrecommendation of magistrate judge)
Doc No. 31-1 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting report andrecommendation of magistrate judge)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/22/2015Criminal No. 00-0033
USA v. Robinson
Doc No. 62 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
01/22/2015Criminal No. 14-0091
USA v. Bailes
Doc No. 16 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/22/2015Criminal No. 10-0037
USA v. Portillo-Vazquez
Doc No. 51 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
01/22/2015Criminal No. 10-0029
USA v. Stefanko
Doc No. 68 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
01/22/2015Criminal No. 09-0042
USA v. Wiley
Doc No. 146 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
01/22/2015Criminal No. 08-0040
USA v. Monchery
Doc No. 74 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
01/21/2015Criminal No. 14-0086
USA v. Wollard
Doc No. 89 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/21/2015Criminal No. 14-0078
USA v. Key
Doc No. 98 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/20/2015Civil Action No. 14-0095
Savage v. Tunnel Ridge, LLC et al
Doc No. 47 (order)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
01/20/2015Civil Action No. 14-0007
Bramwell v. Perdue
Doc No. 33 (memorandum opinion and order)
Doc No. 33-1 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/20/2015Criminal No. 99-0013
USA v. Masko
Doc No. 634 (order affirming and adopting report and recommendations)
Doc No. 634-1 (order affirming and adopting report and recommendations)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/16/2015Civil Action No. 07-0016
Muzichuck v. Forest Laboratories, Inc. et al
Doc No. 182 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/14/2015Civil Action No. 14-0045
St. Paul Mercury Insurance Company v. National Surety Corporation et al
Doc No. 98 (order)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
01/12/2015Civil Action No. 14-0125
Patterson vs. Central Regional Jail
Doc No. 23 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting the report and recommendation of the magistrate judge dismissing with prejudice the civil action)
Doc No. 23-1 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting the report and recommendation of the magistrate judge dismissing with prejudice the civil action)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/12/2015Civil Action No. 14-0036
Emigh v. Commissioner of Social Security
Doc No. 31 (report and recommendation)
 
Magistrate Judge Robert W. Trumble
01/12/2015Civil Action No. 14-0013
Grimes v. Pszczolkowski
Doc No. 38 (order adopting report and recommendation)
Doc No. 38-1 (order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/12/2015Criminal No. 12-0100
USA v. Andrews
Doc No. 586 (order adopting report and recommendation)
Doc No. 587 (order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/12/2015Criminal No. 09-0031
USA v. Sparks
Doc No. 147 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/09/2015Criminal No. 14-0086
USA v. Ferrell
Doc No. 85 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/09/2015Criminal No. 14-0077
USA v. Dejesus
Doc No. 37 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/09/2015Criminal No. 14-0030
USA v. Straughter
Doc No. 53 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/09/2015Criminal No. 14-0030
USA v. Bolyard
Doc No. 52 (order accepting and adopting magistrate judge's opinion)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/09/2015Civil Action No. 14-0037
Pierce v. Commissioner of Social Security
Doc No. 18 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/09/2015Civil Action No. 13-0078
Cunningham Energy, LLC v. Ridgetop Capital II, LP
Doc No. 91 (order)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
01/08/2015Civil Action No. 14-0061
Richardson v. Perdue et al
Doc No. 27 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting report and recommendation of the magistrate judge dismissing without prejudice the civil action)
Doc No. 27-1 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting report and recommendation of the magistrate judge dismissing without prejudice the civil action)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/08/2015Civil Action No. 14-0047
Hammond v. Perdue
Doc No. 27 (order adopting report and recommendation)
Doc No. 27-1 (order adopting report and recommendation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/08/2015Civil Action No. 14-0001
Moorning v. Warden Purdue
Doc No. 28 (report and recommendation)
Doc No. 28-1 (report and recommendation)
Doc No. 28-2 (report and recommendation)
 
Magistrate Judge Robert W. Trumble
01/08/2015Criminal No. 07-0007
USA v. Taylor
Doc No. 80 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/07/2015Civil Action No. 14-0083
Davis v. Commissioner of Social Security
Doc No. 15 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/07/2015Civil Action No. 14-0060
Ross v. Commissioner Of Social Security Administration
Doc No. 16 (order adopting)
Doc No. 16-1 (order adopting)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
01/07/2015Civil Action No. 14-0055
Wyatt v. Capital One Bank (USA), N.A.
Doc No. 35 (memorandum opinion and order)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/07/2015Civil Action No. 14-0043
Clatterbuck v. Commissioner Of Social Security Administration
Doc No. 13 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/07/2015Civil Action No. 13-0215
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Consol Energy, Inc. et al
Doc No. 115 (memorandum opinion and order confirming the pronounced order of the court)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/07/2015Criminal No. 05-0050
USA v. Burns
Doc No. 218 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/07/2015Criminal No. 05-0044
USA v. Myers
Doc No. 96 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Irene M Keeley
01/06/2015Civil Action No. 14-0092
Satcher v. Oddo
Doc No. 10 (order striking petitioner's court)
Doc No. 10-1 (order striking petitioner's court)
 
Magistrate Judge Robert W. Trumble
01/06/2015Civil Action No. 14-0201
Darby v. Federal Bureau of Investigation
Doc No. 9 (report and recommendations)
Doc No. 9-1 (report and recommendations)
Doc No. 9-2 (report and recommendations)
Doc No. 9-3 (report and recommendations)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/06/2015Criminal No. 14-0086
USA v. Ash
Doc No. 79 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/06/2015Criminal No. 14-0031
USA v. Summers
Doc No. 121 (order)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
01/06/2015Civil Action No. 14-0023
Kilgore v. Rubenstein et al
Doc No. 37 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting)
Doc No. 37-1 (memorandum opinion and order affirming and adopting)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/06/2015Civil Action No. 14-0021
Cox v. O'Brien
Doc No. 36 (memorandum opinion and order a)
Doc No. 36-1 (memorandum opinion and order a)
 
District Judge Gina M. Groh
01/06/2015Criminal No. 06-0033
USA v. Flemming
Doc No. 484 (judgment for revocation)
 
District Judge Frederick P Stamp Jr
01/05/2015Criminal No. 14-0086
USA v. Eiseman
Doc No. 76 (opinion)
 
Magistrate Judge John S Kaull
01/05/2015Civil Action No. 14-0022
Campbell v. Commissioner of Social Security
Doc No. 19 (order adopting)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey
01/05/2015Civil Action No. 14-0010
Long v. Policarpio et al
Doc No. 19 (order adopting)
Doc No. 19-1 (order adopting)
 
District Judge John Preston Bailey